Questions on Undocumented Immigrants and Enforcement
What are the risks of being an undocumented person in the U.S.?
The legal risks for undocumented immigrants are that they will be discovered, detained and deported by U.S. authorities. These risks exist whether you own a business in the U.S. or not.
Will the government come after me for my undocumented status if I start a business?
The government does not have any more reason to come after you if you start a business than if you don’t. If the government takes action against you for being an undocumented immigrant, that is likely to be independent of whether you own a business or not.
Are there any U.S. states that are more friendly to businesses owned by undocumented people?
Although we don't have specific information on undocumented business owners, we do have some sources for states and how they treat undocumented immigrants in general.
The Center for Immigration Studies lists 11 states that are known as “Sanctuary” states: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Vermont and Washington. “Anti-sanctuary” states include Arizona, Texas, Montana, Mississippi, Georgia and Alabama.
The New York Times has a guide to states and their approach to undocumented immigrants, including driving licenses, tuition benefits, work permits and other information.
Can owning a business as an undocumented immigrant lessen my chances of being deported?
There’s some anecdotal evidence that owning a business may provide a stronger defense against being deported. A document called “Undocumented Entrepreneurs” states, “Many sections of the Immigration and Nationality Act — including those on relief from removal, inadmissibility, and naturalization — explicitly carve out a role for the immigration judge’s discretion. Property and business ties generally weigh in favor of a positive exercise of discretion.”
Other news stories cite that immigration lawyers bring up business ownership as a defense against enforcement and deportation. Owning a business may also help when it comes to applying for a work visa, residence or citizenship.